Holding Our Nerve: A Yarraville Purchase $125,000 Below Expectations | PHB
Case Study | Concierge

When the Agent Says There Are Other Buyers, Do You Believe Them?

Patrick had found the right home in a tightly held pocket of Yarraville. The vendors wanted $2.2 million. The agent told us he already had buyers at that level. We held our nerve, and bought it for $2.075 million.

Zach DunbarAdvocateZach DunbarBuyer’s Agent
$2.2M
Vendors paid one year earlier
$2.2M
Price they wanted to recover
$2.075M
Patrick’s purchase price
$125K
Below vendor expectation
The Yarraville home Patrick purchased, a two-storey grey home with a white picket fence at dusk

When Patrick engaged Property Home Base through our Concierge service, his brief was very specific. He knew where he wanted to live. Not simply Yarraville generally, but a particular pocket that suited the location and lifestyle he was looking for. The challenge was that there wasn't much available.

We had been actively searching and assessing opportunities for Patrick when a property came onto our radar that genuinely suited what he was looking for. The property itself made sense. The price expectations didn't.

Understanding the Vendor's Position

As part of our due diligence and research, we discovered that the vendors had purchased the property themselves only the year before for $2.2 million. That became an important piece of the puzzle.

The vendors understandably wanted to recover what they had paid for the property and were looking to achieve at least $2.2 million on the resale. But what someone paid for a property previously doesn't necessarily determine what it's worth today.

Our assessment didn't support paying $2.2 million, and we weren't prepared to recommend that Patrick pay it simply to meet the vendors' expectations. So we made an offer at a level we believed represented fair value. Then the pressure started.

“We Already Have Buyers at the Top of the Range”

Over the following weeks, the selling agent continued encouraging us to increase our offer. We were repeatedly told that there were other buyers interested in the property and, importantly, that the agent already had buyers at “the top of the range”, around $2.2 million. If that were true, there was a fairly obvious question:

Why were we still having this conversation?

If another buyer was genuinely prepared and able to purchase the property for $2.2 million, the vendors had every opportunity to accept that offer. Instead, the agent kept coming back to us.

We took that as useful information. Rather than allowing the suggestion of competing buyers to create a fear of missing out, we called the agent's bluff and held our position.

Looking Beyond the Asking Price

There was another important piece of information we had gathered. We knew the vendors had already purchased another property elsewhere. They were under pressure to sell.

That didn't mean they were going to accept any offer put in front of them. They had a very understandable emotional and financial attachment to that $2.2 million figure because it represented what they had paid only a year earlier. But it did mean there was motivation on their side of the negotiation as well.

So we looked at all the information together. The vendors wanted $2.2 million because that was what they had paid. The agent was telling us he had buyers around $2.2 million. Yet weeks later, he was still trying to convince us to increase our offer.

And we knew the vendors had already committed to another property and were increasingly motivated to get this one sold. The picture didn't support us chasing the agent upwards. It supported doing the opposite.

We Let Them Come Back to Us

This is where negotiations can become particularly difficult for buyers. Patrick had a very specific brief. Suitable properties weren't appearing every week, and we had finally found one that worked. That creates a natural temptation to think: Maybe we should just offer another $25,000.

And then another. And another. Before long, a buyer can find themselves negotiating against themselves because they're frightened of losing a property rather than responding to genuine evidence that somebody else is prepared to pay more. We weren't going to let that happen.

For the next few weeks, we remained engaged with the agent, but we refused to be drawn into increasing Patrick's position simply because we were being pressured to do so. If the agent genuinely had a buyer at $2.2 million, we accepted that we could lose the property. But if he didn't, time was increasingly working in our favour.

So we held firm. Eventually, the pressure shifted. The conversation was no longer about how much more Patrick was prepared to pay. It was about whether the vendors were prepared to lose a genuine buyer who was ready to proceed while they were already committed elsewhere.

Ultimately, they weren't. Patrick secured the property for:

$2,075,000

That was $125,000 below what the vendors themselves had paid for the property the previous year, and $125,000 below the $2.2 million figure they had been determined to recover.

How the negotiation unfolded

  1. 1
    The searchProperty identified
  2. 2
    ResearchDue diligence uncovers the $2.2M previous purchase
  3. 3
    The offerOffer submitted
  4. 4
    The pressureAgent claims buyers at about $2.2M
  5. 5
    Several weeksPHB holds firm
  6. 6
    The shiftVendor pressure increases
  7. 7
    The result$2.075M accepted

The Value of Not Getting Caught Up in the Pressure

This negotiation wasn't won through one clever line or a dramatic last-minute offer. It was won through research, information, patience and discipline. Our due diligence helped us understand why $2.2 million mattered so much to the vendors. Our conversations with the selling agent helped us understand the level of pressure on both sides.

Knowing the vendors had already purchased elsewhere helped us understand their motivation to sell. And when we were repeatedly told there were buyers prepared to pay around $2.2 million, we assessed the agent's actions rather than simply accepting the sales pressure at face value.

Most importantly, we were prepared to lose the property rather than allow Patrick to overpay for it. That's an important part of buyer representation.

When you've spent weeks or months searching for a home, particularly within a tightly defined area, it's very easy for scarcity and emotion to take over when the right property finally appears. A good Buyer's Advocate isn't there to encourage you to spend every dollar available just to get the deal done.

Sometimes our job is exactly the opposite. It's to understand the information, remove the emotion from the negotiation and have the confidence to say:

We're comfortable with our position. We're not offering more.

For Patrick, holding that position meant securing the home he wanted in his preferred part of Yarraville for $2.075 million, $125,000 below the price the vendors had been hoping to recover.

Related

Buyer’s Agent ServicesSearch, due diligence, negotiation and bidding.Due DiligenceThe checks to complete before you commit.Buyers vs Sellers MarketHow market conditions change your approach.FeesFlat fees from $2,200, with no percentage of the price.

Book a Free Consultation

Talk through your plans with one of our Advocates and find out which service suits you.

Book a Consultation